The charge is a serious one: suggesting Rachel Reeves has deceived the British public, frightening them into accepting massive extra taxes which would be funneled into increased benefits. While hyperbolic, this is not usual Westminster bickering; this time, the consequences are higher. Just last week, critics aimed at Reeves and Keir Starmer had been labeling their budget "uncoordinated". Today, it is branded as falsehoods, and Kemi Badenoch calling for the chancellor's resignation.
This serious accusation requires straightforward answers, so here is my view. Has the chancellor tell lies? On the available evidence, no. She told no whoppers. But, notwithstanding Starmer's recent remarks, that doesn't mean there's nothing to see and we should move on. Reeves did misinform the public regarding the considerations informing her decisions. Was it to channel cash towards "welfare recipients", as the Tories assert? No, as the figures demonstrate it.
A Standing Takes A Further Hit, But Facts Should Win Out
The Chancellor has sustained another hit to her reputation, however, should facts still have anything to do with politics, Badenoch should stand down her attack dogs. Maybe the resignation yesterday of the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) chief, Richard Hughes, over the unauthorized release of its own documents will satisfy SW1's appetite for scandal.
But the true narrative is far stranger than media reports suggest, extending broader and deeper beyond the careers of Starmer and his class of '24. Fundamentally, herein lies an account about what degree of influence you and I get over the running of the nation. This should concern you.
Firstly, to Brass Tacks
When the OBR published recently some of the projections it shared with Reeves while she prepared the red book, the shock was immediate. Not only has the OBR never done such a thing before (described as an "exceptional move"), its figures apparently contradicted Reeves's statements. Even as leaks from Westminster were about the grim nature of the budget would have to be, the watchdog's predictions were improving.
Consider the Treasury's most "iron-clad" rule, stating by 2030 day-to-day spending for hospitals, schools, and other services would be wholly funded by taxes: at the end of October, the watchdog reckoned this would barely be met, albeit only by a tiny margin.
Several days later, Reeves gave a press conference so unprecedented that it caused breakfast TV to interrupt its usual fare. Several weeks prior to the actual budget, the nation was put on alert: taxes would rise, and the primary cause being gloomy numbers provided by the OBR, in particular its finding that the UK had become less productive, investing more but yielding less.
And so! It came to pass. Despite what Telegraph editorials combined with Tory media appearances implied over the weekend, that is essentially what transpired during the budget, which was significant, harsh, and grim.
The Deceptive Alibi
The way in which Reeves misled us concerned her justification, because those OBR forecasts didn't compel her actions. She could have made different options; she might have given alternative explanations, including on budget day itself. Prior to last year's election, Starmer promised exactly such public influence. "The promise of democracy. The strength of the vote. The possibility for national renewal."
One year later, and it's powerlessness that jumps out from Reeves's breakfast speech. The first Labour chancellor in 15 years portrays herself as a technocrat buffeted by factors outside her influence: "Given the circumstances of the long-term challenges with our productivity … any chancellor of any political stripe would be in this position today, confronting the choices that I face."
She did make decisions, only not the kind the Labour party cares to broadcast. Starting April 2029 British workers and businesses will be contributing another £26bn annually in tax – and most of that will not go towards spent on better hospitals, new libraries, or enhanced wellbeing. Regardless of what nonsense comes from Nigel Farage, Badenoch and others, it isn't getting splashed on "benefits street".
Where the Money Really Goes
Rather than going on services, more than 50% of the additional revenue will in fact provide Reeves a buffer against her own fiscal rules. Approximately 25% is allocated to paying for the administration's policy reversals. Examining the watchdog's figures and being as generous as possible towards Reeves, only 17% of the tax take will go on genuinely additional spending, for example scrapping the limit on child benefit. Removing it "will cost" the Treasury a mere £2.5bn, because it was always an act of theatrical cruelty from George Osborne. This administration could and should abolished it in its first 100 days.
The Real Target: The Bond Markets
The Tories, Reform and all of right-wing media have spent days railing against how Reeves conforms to the caricature of left-wing finance ministers, soaking strivers to fund the workshy. Labour backbenchers have been applauding her budget for being balm for their social concerns, protecting the most vulnerable. Each group are 180-degrees wrong: Reeves's budget was largely targeted towards asset managers, speculative capital and participants within the financial markets.
Downing Street could present a compelling argument for itself. The margins from the OBR were insufficient for comfort, especially considering bond investors charge the UK the highest interest rate of all G7 rich countries – higher than France, that recently lost its leader, and exceeding Japan which has way more debt. Combined with our policies to cap fuel bills, prescription charges as well as train fares, Starmer and Reeves can say their plan allows the central bank to cut its key lending rate.
It's understandable that those folk with Labour badges may choose not to couch it this way next time they visit #Labourdoorstep. As one independent adviser to Downing Street says, Reeves has effectively "weaponised" financial markets as an instrument of discipline against her own party and the electorate. This is the reason Reeves cannot resign, regardless of which promises are broken. It's why Labour MPs must fall into line and support measures that cut billions from social security, as Starmer indicated recently.
Missing Political Vision , an Unfulfilled Promise
What is absent from this is any sense of statecraft, of harnessing the Treasury and the central bank to forge a fresh understanding with investors. Also absent is any intuitive knowledge of voters,